Steven Engelhardt

Roger Lowenstein has written a fascinating article for the New York Times Magazine entitled Triple-A Failure which explores the role of rating agencies in the credit crisis. It even explains the process rating of an actual mortgage-backed security:

The business of assigning a rating to a mortgage security is a complicated affair, and Moody’s recently was willing to walk me through an actual mortgage-backed security step by step. I was led down a carpeted hallway to a well-appointed conference room to meet with three specialists in mortgage-backed paper. Moody’s was fair-minded in choosing an example; the case they showed me, which they masked with the name “Subprime XYZ,” was a pool of 2,393 mortgages with a total face value of $430 million.

…

Moody’s did not have access to the individual loan files, much less did it communicate with the borrowers or try to verify the information they provided in their loan applications. “We aren’t loan officers,” Claire Robinson, a 20-year veteran who is in charge of asset-backed finance for Moody’s, told me. “Our expertise is as statisticians on an aggregate basis. We want to know, of 1,000 individuals, based on historical performance, what percent will pay their loans?”

…

In the frenetic, deal-happy climate of 2006, the Moody’s analyst had only a single day to process the credit data from the bank.

…

Mortgage-backed securities like those in Subprime XYZ were not the terminus of the great mortgage machine. They were, in fact, building blocks for even more esoteric vehicles known as collateralized debt obligations, or C.D.O.’s.

We built a financial house of cards on ratings agencies’ models, and these models turned out to be disastrously wrong.

Guess who People magazine voted the Sexiest Man Alive in 1992?

Read the rest of this entry »

In the course of preparing for Level 1 of the CFA Exam, I learned a few interesting things about the Fed I did not previously know:

• The Fed does not directly control the Federal funds rate. Instead, the Fed publishes a target for the Federal funds rate and attempts to hit it by using open market operations.
• It is a relatively recent development for the Fed to target the Federal funds rate. Before this, the Fed would often target the money supply.
• The Federal Reserve Bank of New York has a special place above all other regional Federal Reserve Banks. The representative from the New York Fed is a permanent member of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), and all open market operations are conducted by the New York Fed under direction from the FOMC.